Yes, but barely, and the headline hides the real story. US existing-home sales rose 1.5% in September to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.99 million, the National Association of Realtors reported Tuesday. Economists had expected a decline. But before you call it a recovery, know this: August and September were the two slowest months for home sales all year.
That tension, a surprise monthly gain inside a slow market, is the story of US housing right now. More homes are sitting on the market than at any point since late 2019. Buyers have more choice and more negotiating power than they have had in years. And yet mortgage rates above 7% keep most would-be buyers on the sideline while prices keep inching up.
Here is what the September numbers actually say, and what they mean if you are buying, selling, or just watching.
What Did US Existing Home Sales Do in September?
Existing-home sales, completed transactions for single-family homes, townhomes, condos, and co-ops, rose 1.5% from August to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.99 million, according to the National Association of Realtors. The gain beat expectations: economists polled by Reuters had forecast a decline to 3.95 million.
Two caveats keep the number in perspective. First, August was revised down to 3.93 million from the 3.98 million first reported, so September’s gain came off a weaker base. Second, sales were still down 2.2% from a year earlier. On a raw, non-seasonally-adjusted basis, Realtor.com notes sales were down 3.9% year over year.
NAR chief economist Lawrence Yun put it plainly: “Despite the small monthly gain on a seasonally adjusted basis, August and September marked the two slowest months for home sales this year.” The surprise was real. A turnaround is not, at least not yet.
Why Did Sales Rise When Mortgage Rates Keep Climbing?
This is the part that confuses people. Mortgage rates did not fall in September. The average 30-year fixed rate was 6.86% in September, up from 6.67% in August and 6.35% a year earlier, according to Freddie Mac figures cited by NAR. And rates have climbed further since: Freddie Mac put the 30-year fixed at 7.40% in the week of October 8, the highest since November 2023.
So why did sales tick up? Timing is a big part of it. Most September closings went under contract in July and August, when rates were closer to 6.7%. As Realtor.com’s research team explains, that rate looks decent now that the market is above 7%, but back in early August it was a 2026 high and the first time in 44 weeks that rates had topped their year-ago level.
Inventory is the other half of the answer. Total housing inventory reached 1.60 million units at the end of September, up 1.9% from August and 4.6% from a year earlier. That is the highest inventory level since November 2019. More listings mean more choice, more negotiating room, and more deals getting done even in a tough rate environment.
The broader rate backdrop is worth understanding. Mortgage rates track the 10-year Treasury yield, and yields have climbed as inflation heated up again. September’s consumer price index came in hotter than expected at 3.7% year over year, which pushed bond yields higher and took mortgage rates with them. The housing market is not moving in isolation. It is downstream of the same inflation fight the Fed is waging.
Where Did Sales Rise and Where Did They Fall?
The national gain was not spread evenly. Sales rose in the South and West, held steady in the Midwest, and fell in the Northeast. Compared with a year earlier, sales were down in all four regions.
- South: up 2.8% from August to a 1.86 million annual pace, down 0.5% year over year. Median price up 0.2%.
- West: up 2.8% to 0.73 million, down 5.2% year over year, the steepest annual drop of any region. Median price down 0.3%, the only region where prices fell.
- Midwest: unchanged at 0.93 million, down 2.1% year over year. Median price up 3.1% to $329,600, more than twice the national rate.
- Northeast: down 2.1% to 0.47 million, down 4.1% year over year. Median price up 4.7%, the strongest price growth in the country.
The regional split tells a familiar story. The West, where prices ran furthest during the pandemic boom, is seeing the sharpest pullback in both sales and prices. The Northeast and Midwest, where homes remain relatively affordable, are still seeing solid price growth even as sales slow.
What Does 4.8 Months of Supply Mean for Buyers?
Months of supply is the housing market’s version of a fuel gauge. It measures how long it would take to sell every home on the market at the current sales pace. In September, unsold inventory represented a 4.8-month supply, unchanged from August and up from 4.5 months a year earlier.
For context, a balanced market is generally considered to be around five to six months of supply. Below that, sellers hold the leverage. Above it, buyers do. At 4.8 months, the market is close to balanced, and buyers have the most choice they have had since 2019.
Homes are also sitting longer. The median time on market was 33 days in September, up from 31 days in August and flat versus a year earlier. That extra time is leverage for buyers. Yun said it directly: “Higher inventory and lengthening days on market give buyers improved negotiating power.”
What does negotiating power look like in practice? Sellers offering price cuts, closing-cost credits, rate buydowns, or repairs they would have refused two years ago. It does not mean sellers are desperate. It means the days of bidding wars over every listing are, for now, over in most markets.
Are Home Prices Still Going Up?
Yes. The median existing-home price was $417,500 in September, up 1.3% from $412,300 a year earlier. That is the 39th straight month of year-over-year price gains, and a record high for the month of September. It is also down 2.4% from August’s $427,700, but month-to-month price moves are seasonal, and September prices almost always dip after the summer peak.
The stubborn price gains are the market’s central frustration. Inventory is up, sales are slow, and prices still refuse to fall. The reason is simple: most homeowners are not forced sellers. Yun noted that the country’s 87 million homeowners are mostly comfortable, having seen substantial wealth gains in recent years compared with before the pandemic. When owners can afford to wait, they do, and that keeps the supply of truly motivated sellers limited.
Affordability, meanwhile, is still getting worse by one key measure. NAR’s Housing Affordability Index registered 105.4 in September, down from 106.7 a year earlier. Affordability fell year over year in the Northeast, Midwest, and South, and improved only in the West. First-time buyers made up 31% of sales, roughly flat with August and a year earlier, while cash sales accounted for 27% and investors and second-home buyers took 20%, up from 15% a year ago.
Realtor.com chief economist Danielle Hale expects the pattern to hold: home sales are likely to remain relatively low for the rest of the year as mortgage rates stay high. The typical asking price has already softened, running 1.4% below last year in September, which suggests sellers are starting to meet buyers partway, even if closed-sale prices have not caught up yet.
What Should Buyers and Sellers Do Now?
If you are buying, this is the best leverage you have had in years, but it comes with a cost. Rates above 7% mean a bigger monthly payment, and waiting for rates to fall is a gamble. One practical move is to shop lenders hard: the spread between the cheapest and most expensive lender can be worth tens of thousands of dollars over the life of a loan. Another is to ask for what the market now allows: price reductions, closing-cost credits, or a rate buydown paid for by the seller. Get pre-approved before you tour homes, and know your ceiling before emotion sets in.
If you are selling, Yun’s advice was blunt: sellers need to be realistic about local market conditions, which could require price discounts and other incentives. Pricing to last year’s comps in a market with 4.8 months of supply is how listings go stale. The homes moving right now are priced for today’s market, presented well, and open to negotiation.
If you are neither, the September report still matters. Housing is the biggest monthly expense for most American families, and it feeds directly into inflation. The same rate pressure squeezing buyers is the reason the Fed is weighing another hike at its October meeting. The housing market will not thaw on its own. It needs either lower rates, lower prices, or both, and right now it has neither.
September’s surprise gain was a welcome flicker, not a fire. Sales beat expectations, inventory is the healthiest in six years, and buyers finally have some power. But with rates at their highest in nearly two years and prices still setting September records, the market is still waiting for the thing that would actually unlock it: a reason for buyers to believe tomorrow will be cheaper than today.



