Yes, a Democrat is really leading in Texas. A new Marist poll released October 14 shows Democratic state Rep. James Talarico at 47% and Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton at 45% among likely voters in the 2026 Texas Senate race, with a margin of error of plus or minus 4.9 points. It’s a slim lead, technically a statistical tie, but it tells the same story poll after poll has told for weeks: in a state that hasn’t sent a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since 1988, this race is genuinely up for grabs.
The forecasters agree. Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball now lists Texas among five Senate tossups, all in Republican-held seats. The Cook Political Report rates it a tossup too. With Election Day on November 3, 2026, just weeks away, here’s what the numbers actually say, and how a race Republicans once considered safe got this close.
What do the latest Texas Senate polls actually show?
The new Marist numbers are the headline, but they’re only part of the picture. A University of Texas/Texas Politics Project poll fielded September 25 to October 5 found Talarico ahead 50% to 47% among likely voters, with a margin of error of 3.3 points. A Fox News poll had Talarico up 51 to 49. And the RealClearPolling average of recent surveys puts the Democrat at 47.0% and Paxton at 45.4%, a 1.6-point edge.
One important detail: not every poll is measuring the same voters. The new Marist survey polled likely voters. Its previous poll, conducted September 17 to 20, surveyed registered voters instead and found Talarico ahead 50% to 44%, with a margin of error of 4.4 points. Registered-voter polls tend to show bigger Democratic leads, so the two results aren’t directly comparable. Still, the direction is consistent.
Not every survey favors Talarico. A Quantus Insights poll taken October 9 to 11 found the race essentially tied. That’s normal polling noise, and it doesn’t change the overall pattern: since the May primary runoff, nearly every major poll has shown either a narrow Talarico lead or a dead heat. Nobody is finding a comfortable Paxton advantage.
Why did forecasters move Texas to a tossup?
Twenty-four hours can say a lot. Sabato’s Crystal Ball updated its ratings on October 14, declaring five Senate tossups: Kansas, Iowa, Maine, Ohio, and Texas. Every one of them is a Republican-held seat. As the Crystal Ball team put it, Republicans now need to win four of those five to keep their Senate majority.
The reason Texas made the list isn’t really about Talarico’s polling alone. It’s about who the Republican nominee is. Ken Paxton is the sitting Texas attorney general, a conservative firebrand with Donald Trump’s full backing. He’s also a candidate who survived a 2023 impeachment by the Texas House, years of criminal legal trouble, and a very public marriage breakdown. Cook’s Jessica Taylor and other analysts have argued for months that Paxton is the kind of nominee who can turn a safe seat competitive.
Then there’s the history working against him. Texas hasn’t elected a Democrat to statewide office since 1994, and its last Democratic senator, Lloyd Bentsen, won reelection in 1988. For the top forecasters to call this race a tossup in a state that red, something fundamental had to shift. The polls did it.
How did Ken Paxton end up as the Republican nominee?
Republicans were warned. Incumbent Sen. John Cornyn, a four-term senator, argued during the primary that nominating Paxton would put a safe seat in jeopardy. But primary voters wanted a fighter, and Donald Trump gave them permission: days before the May runoff, Trump endorsed Paxton over Cornyn, and Paxton won the nomination.
That endorsement has become the hinge of the whole race. Trump carried Texas by 14 points in the 2024 presidential election, and the Republican playbook assumed that redness would carry down the ballot. Instead, Paxton’s nomination put the party in a defensive crouch in a state where it usually plays offense. Outside money is now flooding in to hold the seat, and Republican strategists are spending resources in Texas that were supposed to go elsewhere.
What happened at the CNN town hall on October 14?
For one evening, Talarico had the spotlight entirely to himself. On October 14, CNN aired a live town hall with the Democratic nominee from Fort Worth, moderated by Erin Burnett and co-produced with Jubilee Media, the YouTube giant behind the “Surrounded” debate series. Talarico answered questions from a live audience of Texas voters, including Democrats, Republicans, and independents.
Paxton was invited. He didn’t come. According to reporting on the event, Paxton’s camp declined the CNN invitation, arguing the network’s moderators would be biased, and as of October he still hadn’t agreed to any televised debate with Talarico. His team has preferred to campaign through ads and surrogates rather than put the candidate on a stage with his opponent.
Skipping debates can be a rational move for a front-runner. But Paxton isn’t running like a front-runner in the polls, and Talarico has made the debate standoff itself a talking point, framing his opponent as unwilling to face Texas voters directly. The empty chair at a nationally televised town hall gave that argument three weeks of oxygen before Election Day.
How damaging is the Dubai video story for Paxton?
On October 13, the Wall Street Journal reported that it had reviewed video footage showing Paxton celebrating New Year’s Eve 2024 in Dubai with two Americans who had already been indicted on federal healthcare-fraud charges. The men, Anosh Ahmed and Sameer Suhail, were charged in Illinois with embezzling $15 million from a Chicago hospital. Ahmed faces a separate, much larger case involving at least $195 million in alleged fraudulent COVID-19 testing payments.
The footage, reportedly shot on a luxury high-rise balcony as fireworks lit up the Burj Khalifa, also shows Paxton with Tracy Duhon, identified as his girlfriend. The Journal reported that Ahmed donated $190,000 to Paxton, including $25,000 that arrived days after Ahmed’s indictment. Both men were wanted by U.S. Marshals at the time of the party, according to the reporting.
Paxton’s campaign has not commented on the footage. To be fair, the story fits a pattern the candidate has already survived: the impeachment, the criminal cases, the corruption allegations. Republican voters in the primary knew about plenty of Paxton scandals and nominated him anyway. But three weeks before a general election, with independents and soft Republicans deciding a tossup race, a video of the state’s top law enforcement officer partying with wanted fugitives is a harder sell. One poll found 51% of voters view Paxton unfavorably, compared with 38% for Talarico, and Fox’s survey found a majority worry that Paxton is too close to Trump.
Could a Democrat really win statewide in Texas?
The honest answer: nobody has done it in a generation, and plenty of smart people have bet on it and lost. Texas Democrats have seen promising polls before, only to watch them evaporate on Election Day. The polling errors of 2016, 2020, and 2024 mostly underestimated Republicans, and Texas pollsters know their history.
But there are real reasons this year looks different. Talarico is winning independents by wide margins. He leads Paxton on the cost of living, 49% to 42%, in recent issue polling, in a cycle where affordability is voters’ top concern. And unlike a presidential year, Donald Trump isn’t on the ballot to drag Republican turnout skyward. Midterm electorates behave differently, and Texas Democrats are betting the enthusiasm gap favors them.
The structural math still favors Republicans. Texas is an R+6 state at the presidential level, and early voting dynamics could tighten everything again. Prediction markets give Talarico better odds than the polling average alone would suggest, but nobody who remembers Texas politics takes that as a guarantee.
What’s next before November 3?
Three things to watch. First, the debate question: will Paxton ever agree to face Talarico on a stage before Election Day? Second, the money: national Republicans are pouring outside spending into Texas to keep the seat, resources they’d rather use in Maine or Ohio. Third, early voting, which will show whether the polling energy translates into actual ballots cast.
Texas has had competitive Senate races before. It has never had a Republican nominee quite like Ken Paxton facing a Democrat quite like James Talarico. The 2026 Texas Senate race is a genuine tossup, and for the first time in decades, the path to a Senate majority might run straight through the Lone Star State.



